Working one mitten at a time.
With right sides facing together, align UNDER MITT (2) with THUMB PANEL (3) piece and sew together along the curve with a ¼” seam allowance. Press seam allowance open.
Next, fold the THUMB PANEL (3) piece right sides together to align the curved ends. Sew together with ¼” seam allowance.
Next, align UPPER MITT (1) piece with the UNDER and THUMB pieces with RIGHT sides together. Sew along the outer edges with a ¼” seam allowance in two steps:
From circle to outer edge (sewing along the long curved edge).
From circle to bottom edge (sewing along the short straight edge).
Lastly, insert the cuffs into the mitten, aligning the wrist edge with the cut edge of the cuffs, with right sides together. Sew together with a ½” seam allowance.
Tun mitt right side out.
Repeat with the other mitten to complete the pair.